STUDY | COMPARISON | DOSAGE/DETAILS | PARTICIPANTS | N (Rx/C) | OUTCOME | ROB 2
PEDRo |
BOSWELL-RUYS 2020 | Resistive Inspiratory muscle training (RMT)
V
Sham RMT | 3-5 sets 12 breaths 2 x day 5 days per week for 6 weeks
@ > 30% MIP | C4-C8 SCI
AIS A, B, C
> 4 weeks post-injury | 29/31 | Maximal Inspiratory pressure (MIP) | Very low Risk of Bias
PEDro = 10/10 |
Liaw 2000 | Inspiratory muscle training
(& usual care)
V
Usual care | 15-20 minutes 2 x day; 7 days per week for 6/52 | C4-C7 complete SCI
< 6 months post-injury | 10/10 | Maximal Inspiratory pressure (MIP) | High Risk of Bias
PEDro = 4/10 |
LITCHKE 2008 | Respiratory resistance training
V
No intervention | 1 set of exercises 2-3 x per day daily for 10 weeks | >80% participants with SCI
C5-T12 SCI
> 6 months post-injury | 4/5 | Maximal Inspiratory pressure (MIP) | Some Concerns about Risk of Bias
PEDro = 5/10 |
LITCHKE 2011 | Concurrent flow resistance
V
No intervention | 10 breaths 3 different x per day daily for 9 weeks | >80% participants with SCI
C5-C7 SCI | 5/7 | Maximal Inspiratory pressure (MIP) | High Risk of Bias
PEDro = 3/10 |
LOVERIDGE 1989 | Concurrent flow resistance
V
No intervention | 85% of sustained inspiratory pressure 2 x day for 15 minutes 5 days per week for 8 weeks | C6-C7 complete SCI >1 year post-injury | 6/6 | Maximal Inspiratory pressure (MIP) | Some Concerns about Risk of Bias
PEDro = 4/10 |
MUELLER 2013 | Inspiratory resistance training
V
placebo | 90 breaths @ > 80% max inspiratory power
4 x per week for 8 weeks | C6-C7 complete SCI >1 year post-injury | 8/8 | Maximal Inspiratory pressure (MIP) | Some Concerns about Risk of Bias
PEDro = 4/10 |
POSTMA 2014 | Resistive Inspiratory muscle training (& usual care)
V
Usual care | 90 breaths @ > 80% max inspiratory power
4 x per week for 8 weeks | T12 and above SCI AIS A-D initial rehab
FEV1 <80% predicted | 19/21 | Maximal Inspiratory pressure (MIP) | High Risk of Bias
PEDro = 7/10 |
ROTH 2010 | Expiratory muscle training
V
Sham | Exp muscle resistive training 10 reps, twice a day, 5 x per week for 6 weeks | T1 and above motor complete SCI | 16/13 | Maximal Inspiratory pressure (MIP) | High Risk of Bias
PEDro = 4/10 |
SOUMYASHREE 2018 | Inspiratory muscle training
V
Breathing exercises | 15 minutes @ 40 MIP 5 x per week for 4 weeks | T1-12 SCI
AIS A-D | 15/12 | Maximal Inspiratory pressure (MIP) | Some Concerns of Risk of bias
PEDro = 7/10 |
WEST 2014 | Inspiratory muscle training
V
Sham | 30 breaths at 50-60% Pimax 2 x day 5 days per week for 6 weeks | C5-C7 SCI
AIS A or B
≥3 years post-injury | 5/5 | Maximal Inspiratory pressure (MIP) | High Risk of Bias
PEDro = 4/10 |